VIEWPOINT Hurricane winds drive market forces to disrupt agriculture's busy season
By Don Copenhaver, president
Two hurricanes hammer the Gulf Coast and agriculture absorbs
the blows. Not for a minute do I want to minimize the human suffering involved
for the victims of hurricanes Katrina and Rita. My heart goes out to those
involved. In fact, here at MFA Incorporated, we furnished two trucks to deliver
supplies as well as several tons of cattle feed to the area. And over at our
sister cooperative, MFA Oil, they sent a tractor-trailer full of diesel. But
these hurricanes couldn't have come at a worse time for agriculture. Right in
the middle of grain and fertilizer movement. Agronomists are even speculating
that the hurricane-force winds have increased the Midwest's chances of
developing soybean rust next growing season.
One of the worst aspects from a financial perspective is
that everything is going in the wrong direction. Grain market forces point to
high transportation prices. The plant food industry is just shy of chaos. And
farmers are waiting until the last minute to decide orders. I can tell you with
certainty that growers moving slowly or trying to wait out a market correction
are playing with fire. Fertilizer is coming from long distances in this market.
Right now at MFA, our plant foods people are working three to six months out.
It will be very easy to wait too long and be unable to obtain adequate
fertilizer supply. From an industry standpoint, the days are gone of having
full warehouses of product waiting idly for orders. Too many market factors
demand planning.
From a business standpoint, MFA Incorporated was affected by
the hurricanes. Our farm supply division has eight truckloads of sisal twine
stranded in a warehouse outside of New Orleans. It is inaccessible as of this
writing and its condition is unknown. Our plant foods division lost a barge
full of urea. Urea is water soluble. When the insurance adjustors opened the
flooded barge, they found—nothing. In another instance, we had 15
railcars of urea caught in the middle of the hurricane. Each and every car
sustained significant water damage resulting in a complete loss of product. Our
grand total fertilizer loss for just those two incidents added up to 3,000
tons.
Two different barge lines we deal with each lost track of
100 barges. Several weeks after the hurricanes, both barge lines had accounted
for all of those barges. Trouble is, many of those barges were in places other
than the river and are out of commission indefinitely. Barge freight in October
was trading at 800 percent of tariff. There is a tremendous disruption in the
grain industry. Loan Deficiency Payments will again be a large factor in farm
income. But LDPs are based on historic freight and basis price at the Gulf.
Given today's conditions, those LDPs will be below actual cost.
At the Gulf, natural gas prices are again setting records.
And U.S. natural gas companies are declaring force majeure or Act of God. That
means the companies do not have to honor existing contracts. Translated
further, that means all bets are off in the fertilizer market. Given gas and
energy costs, there is no sign that nitrogen will go down in the near term. As
of this writing, October and November natural gas futures were trading near $14
per million British thermal unit (btu). In 2004, the market average was $5.85.
Suppliers tell us that it's a certainty natural gas, during this winter futures
market, will trade above $10.
Many farmers are waiting for offshore supplies to drop
market prices. It looks to be a long wait. Russian and Middle Eastern suppliers
are taking notice of our high prices and will divert ships to the United
States. They can supply U.S. demand. But the marketplace cannot respond in a
timely fashion. There is no guarantee prices will drop in time for spring
fieldwork. Simply put, supply is tight and cost is high. All indications that
we're getting say nitrogen prices will stay high through the Midwest's spring
planting season. World supply and demand drive prices in the fertilizer market.
You can argue that's a good thing or a bad thing. But regardless of your
position, market forces affect fertilizer price. Last year world fertilizer
demand increased 13 percent, nearly equivalent to the total use in the United
States. According to The Fertilizer Institute, over the last four years, world
nitrogen demand has grown 10 percent, phosphate demand by 13 percent and potash
demand by 25 percent. From a company standpoint, we will adjust and maneuver
and fight our way through this and provide you with the best price and supply
that we can negotiate with the industry.
As a result of all this fertilizer volatility, many
producers are thinking seriously of switching from corn to soybeans. It's a
rational thought considering today's prices. But is it the right move? Despite
what anyone tells you, only next year's crop conditions, harvest and prices
will prove whether the decision is correct or not. Agronomists worry that the
two hurricanes in places with confirmed cases of rust have provided just the
right conditions to spread rust further north. If that occurs, all soybean bets
are off.
Of course, from a selfish standpoint, I want producers to
plant corn. The reason I do is simple. We have a new corn selection called
MorCorn that we expect to be an excellent product. We expect sales of MorCorn
to be substantial. But seriously, MFA is a cooperative dedicated to serving its
members. When our members prosper, so do we. Let's just hope we all navigate
this treacherous fall safely.
|