MFA Vision - Growth - Success By Don Copenhaver
The fiscal year ended Aug. 31, 2005, was one of the best ever for MFA Incorporated. In large part, the record results came from the previous year's bin-busting yields and well-managed joint ventures. MFA's president and CEO detailed MFA's performance to the 863 people attending the cooperative's annual meeting Nov. 29, 2005.
We just completed an excellent year as it relates to
profitability on our own operations. A lot of things worked in our favor. The
fall of 2004 was one of the best crop harvests our trade area has ever
experienced. Two-hundred-bushel corn was common. Soybean yields were
outstanding as well.
The grain side of our business reflected these results.
Unfortunately this past fall's harvest (which will be reflected in this current
fiscal year) will not be as rewarding. A large part of our trade territory
experienced very dry conditions, so we will handle fewer bushels during our
2006 fiscal year.
We also enjoyed outstanding results from our joint ventures.
When those joint ventures were entered, there was some concern about MFA taking
money away from traditional locations. History has proven the wisdom of these
decisions. The profit generated has allowed us to make improvements to
traditional facilities. A good example is the $6 million we spent this past
year upgrading several grain-handling facilities.
Cooperatives finance themselves by generating profit or by
taking on debt. Given a choice, I would rather rely on profitability,
especially in a rising interest-rate environment like today.
We enjoyed a very good gain on the sale of our CF Industries
stock. CF was an interregional fertilizer manufacturing cooperative created by
MFA and seven other regional cooperatives scattered across the United States.
Over the years, we enjoyed good revenue from that investment, but about eight
years ago, CF started losing money because of off-shore competition and rising
natural gas prices. They lost about $350 million during those eight years. As a
result, the $36 million investment reflected on our balance sheet was not
generating return.
MFA had a seat on the board of directors as well as a stockholder representative. I was
that board member. Lester Evans, chairman of the corporate board for
MFA, was MFA's stockholder representative.
A year ago, the CF board explored putting CF on the market.
Fortunately, the newly appointed chief executive officer of
CF convinced the board to take the company public. Our timing was perfect. The
initial public offering was $16 per share. Our portion netted MFA $39.5
million. Keep in mind our investment was $36 million. We realized a gain of
$3.5 million.
The MFA board of directors voted to pay a patronage dividend
on current year earnings, as well as retire the balance of the 1975 equity. The
current year patronage will be based on paying 60 percent in cash and the
balance in equity. Our cash outlay will total $9.6 million. Of that, $3.8
million of cash will go to Uncle Sam for taxes on non-member income, primarily
from our share of earnings on our joint ventures. IRS does not allow us to pay
patronage on non-member business. We are required to take that revenue to
retained earnings and pay income taxes on that amount.
No doubt, some of you will wonder why more current year
patronage was not paid based on the level of earnings we enjoyed this past
year. Again, it relates to the high levels of earnings generated from our joint
venture operations that are considered by the IRS as being non-member earnings
and not available for distribution. At the March delegate meetings we will
spend more time on this process.
The new fiscal year is setting itself up to be challenging.
Fertilizer prices are being driven by high natural gas prices and
transportation costs. These extremely high values on fertilizer are causing us
to think carefully on how much fertilizer we commit to. There is tremendous
downside risk. Given the tonnage we move annually (1.5 million tons), we cannot
wait until the last minute. We simply have to lock in a portion of our needs
early to have it in position for spring. But how much do we lock in not knowing
what you, the customer, will do come spring?
Before all the consolidation among the fertilizer
manufacturers, we would line up a supply and pay for the product at time of
delivery. In many cases, we would have price protection. If the price fell
before we took delivery, we would get the lower price. Those days are gone. Now
we must pay for the product before we take delivery and without the advantage
of price protection. We stand all the risk.
If we were to decide to fill our available space of 350,000
tons at today's values, we would tie up nearly $100 million in working capital.
To give you an idea of the tremendous downside risk, assume the price would go
down an average of $100 per ton between the time we pay for it and spring
application. If my math is right, that equates to a $35 million loss. That is
too much risk for MFA to assume.
So I hope you understand the dilemma. Do we fill a
substantial portion of our space now and assume the downside risk, or do we
simply fill a small portion and risk not being able to supply all needs next
spring?
From a logistical standpoint, we cannot move our fertilizer
volume if we wait until spring to book it. Today's transportation modes are
unreliable and costly. Service has been horrible, and rate structure
ridiculously high. That leaves us dependent on truck freight and the resulting
fuel surcharges.
Increased gasoline and diesel fuel prices affect us just
like they affect you. MFA uses approximately 1.5 million gallons of fuel on an
annual basis in our vehicles and equipment. We use a significant amount of
propane and natural gas to dry grain and to heat our facilities. Assuming fuel
stays at these price levels, our annual cost will increase by some $1.7
million.
Our theme for this year is Vision, Growth, Success. Last
year we shared our vision for the company with you. We continue to focus on
that vision. We, as employees of this organization, know why MFA was formed in
the first place—to provide economic benefit for member-owners.
We have grown the company through joint ventures and through
acquisitions that have produced positive results. We will continue to look for
opportunities to grow the company in a prudent and responsible manner.
Our balance sheet is in good shape. It allows us to take
advantage of opportunities. The fact we have been around for nearly 92 years
speaks volumes for our success. Our financial performance exemplifies success.
As employees of this company, we are committed to build on our success.
Thank you for your continued support and for allowing us to
serve you. We cannot be successful without it.
If achievement and success are measured by bottom line
results, then 2005 was a successful year with net income of $15 million. A
record grain harvest in the fall of 2004, improved margins on the sale of
supply products, good profitability in our swine marketing division and a gain
on the sale of a major investment all contributed to this profit improvement.
The numbers include the combined activity of MFA
Incorporated, our wholly owned subsidiary MFA Enterprises, our finance company
Agmo Corporation, and a 100-percent-owned limited liability company, West
Central AGRIServices.
It all starts with sales volume. Sales and service revenue
dollars totaled $969 million, an increase of $110 million. A 50 percent
improvement in grain unit volume and record high plant food prices were the
main factors for the increase.
Grain bushels sold increased from 43 million last year to 65
million this year. The 2004 harvest produced record and near record yields for
corn and soybeans. Missouri soybean production was up 52 percent, and corn
production was up 54 percent.
Dollar sales of grain sold totaled $258 million, about a 13
percent increase. With increased production levels, unit prices were lower. So,
even though unit volumes were up over 50 percent, dollar volumes only increased
by 13 percent.
The additional grain volume did have a positive impact on
storage and drying revenue. Combined, these two revenue items were up nearly $2
million over last year.
Field crops
Field crop sales produced revenues of $531 million, an increase
of $79 million. Of the $531 million, plant food sales represent $385 million,
up $71 million from last year. Wholesale tonnage totaled 1.6 million, up about
6 percent. Crop protection volume is $108 million, up $7 million from last
year. Most of this increase was at the wholesale level and concentrated in the
Delta area and the Mid-South.
Seed sales were $38 million, up $1 million from last year. A
decline in wheat seed due to the wet fall was offset by a 15 percent increase
in corn units and a modest increase in soybean units.
Livestock supply
Livestock supply sales totaled $131 million, up slightly
from last year. Feed was the largest contributor at $84 million. Dollar sales
were identical to last year; however, unit volume increased by 28,000 tons.
Lower ingredient prices kept dollar sales flat. Beef feed tons increased 12
percent. Cattle Charge led all other beef feeds in tons sold, and after 10
years on the market, Cattle Charge had sales of more than 56,000 tons. Dairy
feed, minerals and specialty feeds, particularly poultry and goat, had unit
increases.
Farm supply sales were $32, up $1 million from last year. Again, the dollar increase were
the result of higher prices, particularly steel products. Unit volume was down
in wire and steel products as well as twine.
These declines were offset by increases in livestock
equipment,in particular portable cattle feeders.
Animal health sales were $15 million in both years. Unit
volume showed some increase, with lower prices per unit due to the increased
usage of generic products.
MFA's total operating margin (gross margins on products sold
and the income from service revenues) stood at $145 million this year, up from
$129 million last year.
Expenses were $130 million, up $9 million or 7 percent. Employee
costs (payroll and fringe benefits) comprise 56 percent of all expenses. These
costs increased 4 percent to $73 million. On a percentage basis, the most
significant expense increases were car and truck and interest expense, both up
23 percent. Revenues of $145 million, less expenses of $130 million, result in
a profit of $15 million.
The balance sheet
Current assets (primarily receivables and inventory) are
$227 million, an increase of $31 million. Record high prices of plant food
products caused an increase in inventory and accounts receivable of $20
million. Crop protection product inventories are up nearly $7 million.
Investments, our ownership in interregional cooperatives and
joint ventures, were $33 million, down from $67 million. See Don Copenhaver's
article on page 8 for more information on the sale of our investment in CF
Industries.
Fixed assets (land, buildings, equipment and rolling stock)
are $73million, an increase of $3 million. New and replacement asset additions
totaled $15 million. This was offset by depreciation expense of $12 million.
During the year, the MFA board of directors approved expenditures of $6.3 million to
improve and upgrade grain receiving, storing and handling capacity at strategic
grain locations.
Total assets are $333 million in both years. The reduction
in investments due to the sale of CF stock is offset by the higher values for
plant food and crop protection inventories.
Net worth is the equity allocated to members and the
after-tax income on non-member, non-patronage business—$120 million, an
increase of $5 million.
For 2005, the MFA board of directors approved cash
distributions to the members of $5.8 million. This amount is broken down into
patronage on current year business of $5.3 million, of which 60 percent, or
$3.2 million, will be paid as a cash distribution. An additional $2.6 million
will also be paid to complete the retirement of 1975 allocated equities.
Working capital, or current assets minus current
liabilities, increased$33 million to $97 million. Proceeds from the CF investment
were usedprimarily to pay short-term debt, creating an improvement in working capital. The percentage
of assets owned by the members increased from 35 percent to 36 percent.
The financial strength of the organization is at an all-time
high. The achievements and results of this past year will, however, be
difficult to duplicate in 2006.
Grain yields this fall were down considerably from those of
the previous year. Record high fertilizer prices are causing producers to take
a wait and see attitude toward planting intentions for next spring. High-cost
diesel is also impacting this decision. The availability of transportation to
move product remains uncertain. I expect interest rates to continue to increase
throughout 2006. Despite these challenges, MFA expects to have another profitable
year.
|